The hiding power of a paint determines how effectively it conceals the color and contrast of the substrate beneath it, making it one of the most important performance properties in coatings formulation and quality control. ASTM test methods such as D344, D2805, D5150, and D6441 provide standardized, reproducible procedures for measuring the opacity of liquid architectural paints and powder coatings alike. This technical article explains the principles, sample requirements, testing procedures, and practical applications of ASTM hiding power tests.
Technical Overview
Hiding power, also referred to as opacity or covering power, is the ability of a dried paint film to obliterate the color or color differences of the surface on which it is applied. In quantitative terms, hiding power is expressed either as the contrast ratio of a film applied at a fixed spreading rate, or as the spreading rate — in square meters per liter (m²/L) or square feet per gallon (ft²/gal) — at which the film achieves a defined level of hiding, most commonly a contrast ratio of 0.98.
The contrast ratio is calculated as CR = YB/YW in concept, where YB and YW are the green tristimulus reflectance values of the film measured over black and white substrates respectively. A contrast ratio approaching 1.00 indicates essentially complete hiding. ASTM International publishes several standardized methods for evaluating this property, and the most widely used include:
- ASTM D344 — Relative hiding power of paints by visual evaluation of brushouts
- ASTM D2805 — Hiding power of paints by reflectometry, based on Kubelka-Munk analysis
- ASTM D5150 — Hiding power of architectural paints by instrumental measurement of small areas drawn on black and white charts
- ASTM D6441 — Hiding power of powder coatings by colorimetric measurement over black and white substrates
- ASTM D5007 — Wet-to-dry hiding change of architectural paints
Supporting standards include ASTM D823 for producing uniform test films, ASTM D2244 for calculating color differences from instrumentally measured coordinates, and the closely related ISO 6504-1 method for international specifications.
Testing Samples
Architectural Coatings
Waterborne and solvent-borne interior and exterior paints, from flat to gloss finishes, as well as stain-blocking primers, are the most common samples for ASTM D344, D5150, and D2805 testing. These products are evaluated as liquid samples applied to black-and-white contrast charts or glass panels.
Industrial and Protective Coatings
Enamels, maintenance coatings, coil coatings, and other industrial finishes can be tested using ASTM D2805 on glass panels or ASTM D5150 on contrast charts, depending on the application method and target film thickness.
Powder Coatings
Thermosetting and thermoplastic powder coatings are evaluated under ASTM D6441 by applying the powder onto black and white metal panels and measuring the color difference after full cure at the manufacturer's recommended schedule.
Sample Submission and Conditioning
- Liquid paints: typically 0.5 to 1 liter per sample is sufficient for multiple drawdowns at several film builds.
- Powder coatings: generally 200 to 500 g, accompanied by the recommended cure temperature and time.
- Condition all samples at 23 ± 2 °C and 50 ± 5 % relative humidity before testing, and mix thoroughly to ensure uniform pigment dispersion.
- Provide product information such as coating type, color, and target dry film thickness to ensure the correct method and reporting basis are selected.
Testing Items
Depending on the standard selected and the specification requirements, the following properties can be reported by accredited third-party laboratories:
- Relative hiding power, expressed as a percentage of a reference paint — ASTM D344
- Absolute hiding power as spreading rate at 0.98 contrast ratio, in m²/L or ft²/gal — ASTM D2805
- Contrast ratio at a specified spreading rate, for example 400 ft²/gal (approximately 9.8 m²/L) — ASTM D5150
- Color difference (ΔE*) between films applied over black and white substrates at a specified thickness — ASTM D6441
- Wet-to-dry hiding change, expressed as a percentage loss of hiding upon drying — ASTM D5007
- Film thickness at complete hiding, when a thickness ladder drawdown is performed
Testing Methods
All methods begin with the preparation of uniform, reproducible films in accordance with ASTM D823, using film applicators, drawdown bars, spray application, or brushout as appropriate. Films are dried under standard laboratory conditions, typically 24 to 48 hours at 23 ± 2 °C and 50 ± 5 % relative humidity, before evaluation.
ASTM D344 — Visual Evaluation of Brushouts
The test paint and a reference paint are brushed side by side at identical spreading rates onto a suitable white substrate. Trained observers compare the regions where hiding is incomplete, and the relative hiding power of the test paint is reported as a percentage of the reference. This method is simple, practical, and closely reflects real brush application behavior, which makes it useful for field-oriented comparisons even though it is subjective.
ASTM D2805 — Hiding Power by Reflectometry
Films are drawn at several thicknesses onto paired black and white glass panels. The reflectance of each film over the black and white areas is measured with a reflectometer or spectrophotometer, and contrast ratios are calculated at each thickness. From these data, the Kubelka-Munk scattering and absorption coefficients are derived, and the spreading rate that produces a contrast ratio of 0.98 is computed and reported as the hiding power. ASTM D2805 is an absolute instrumental method, harmonized in principle with ISO 6504-1, and is widely cited in specifications and certification programs.
ASTM D5150 — Instrumental Measurement on Black and White Charts
A series of small rectangular areas of paint is drawn at progressively increasing film thickness on a sealed black-and-white contrast chart, forming a thickness ladder. After drying, the reflectance over the black and white halves of each area is measured, and contrast ratio is plotted against spreading rate. The contrast ratio at a specified spreading rate, or conversely the spreading rate at a specified contrast ratio, is reported. ASTM D5150 is fast, objective, economical in sample consumption, and correlates well with ASTM D2805, making it the routine method of choice for architectural paints.
ASTM D6441 — Hiding Power of Powder Coatings
The powder is electrostatically sprayed onto smooth black and white panels at controlled film thickness, then fully cured according to the specified schedule. CIELAB color coordinates are measured over the black and white substrates in accordance with ASTM D2244, and hiding power is judged from the color difference between the two measurements. A ΔE* approaching zero indicates complete hiding, and the method also allows determination of the minimum film thickness at which visual or instrumental hiding is achieved.
ASTM D5007 — Wet-to-Dry Hiding Change
Parallel films are applied to a contrast chart: one is protected to remain wet while the other is allowed to dry. The wet and dry films are compared visually or instrumentally, and the loss of hiding upon drying is reported as a percentage. This method is valuable during formulation development because significant wet-to-dry hiding loss signals binder-pigment interactions such as poor film formation or pigment flooding.
Applications
- Quality control of production batches to verify batch-to-batch consistency of opacity.
- Formulation development, including optimization of titanium dioxide loading, extender selection, and hollow-sphere opacity pigments.
- Cost-reduction studies and competitive benchmarking of commercial paints.
- Compliance verification against product specifications for architectural, industrial, and powder coating projects.
- Support for ecolabel and environmental certification programs that set minimum contrast ratio or spreading rate requirements.
- Verification of powder coating opacity for appliance, furniture, automotive component, and general metal finishing applications.
- Generation of reliable data for technical data sheets and regulatory submissions by manufacturers and accredited third-party laboratories.
FAQ
What is the difference between contrast ratio and hiding power?
The contrast ratio is the measured ratio of the reflectance of a film over a black substrate to its reflectance over a white substrate at a given film thickness or spreading rate. Hiding power is the broader performance property; quantitatively it is usually expressed as the spreading rate at which the film reaches a specified contrast ratio, commonly 0.98. A higher spreading rate at the same contrast ratio indicates better hiding power.
Which ASTM method should I choose for an architectural paint?
ASTM D5150 is the most practical choice for routine architectural paint evaluation because it is instrumental, rapid, and requires relatively little material. ASTM D2805 provides an absolute hiding power value based on Kubelka-Munk analysis and is preferred for formal specifications and certification. ASTM D344 remains useful when brush application behavior and practical, job-site hiding are of primary interest.
How much sample is required for testing?
For liquid paints, 0.5 to 1 liter is typically sufficient for multiple drawdowns at several film builds. Powder coating testing under ASTM D6441 generally requires 200 to 500 g of material together with the recommended cure schedule. Exact quantities should always be confirmed with the testing laboratory before submission.
What result is considered acceptable?
Acceptance criteria depend entirely on the product specification. As a common benchmark for interior architectural paints, a contrast ratio of at least 0.98 at a spreading rate of about 400 ft²/gal (approximately 9.8 m²/L) is regarded as very good hiding. For powder coatings, specifications typically set a maximum allowable ΔE* between black and white substrates at the specified film thickness, with lower values indicating better opacity.
Do laboratory hiding power results predict real-world coverage?
Laboratory drawdowns and brushouts correlate well with practical application when the paint is applied at similar wet film thicknesses. However, on-site substrate texture and color, application method, and operator technique can shift the actual coverage obtained. Hiding power data should therefore be treated as a controlled comparative measure rather than an absolute field guarantee.
Can hiding power testing help reduce formulation cost?
Yes. Because titanium dioxide is usually the most expensive component contributing to opacity, ASTM D2805 and D5150 data allow formulators to balance pigment loading against hiding requirements precisely. Small, statistically valid improvements in spreading rate at 0.98 contrast ratio can translate into significant raw material savings at production scale.
Why Choose ZKGX?
- State-of-the-art analytical equipment
- Highly qualified scientific team
- Fast turnaround time
- Competitive pricing